Credentialing Program Design Consulting
Last updated: October 2026
Credentialing program design is the work of building the policies, committee structure, verification procedures and monitoring routines an organization uses to credential the providers it contracts with, employs or delegates to, and Integral Healthcare Solutions (IHS) builds that program for organizations that need one without pursuing NCQA accreditation.
IHS was founded in 2002 by Thomas G. Goddard, JD, PhD, former Chief Operating Officer and General Counsel of URAC. Credentialing program design sits in IHS's Program Development practice line, and Dr. Goddard leads it. IHS drafts the program, policies and clinical content for your clinicians to review and approve, and your team operates the program. Maureen Plumstead leads NCQA accreditation and recognition engagements, which are a separate service.
What is a healthcare credentialing program?
A healthcare credentialing program is the structured system an organization uses to verify provider qualifications, monitor them over time, and make enrollment or retention decisions through a formal committee process. It has five working parts:
- Primary source verification (PSV): confirming a provider's education, training, board certification, licenses and registrations directly with the issuing source rather than from copies or self-attestation.
- Ongoing monitoring: recurring checks of enrolled providers against federal and state exclusion and sanction sources, with a written escalation path when a hit appears.
- A credentialing committee: a chartered body with defined membership, quorum, voting rights and conflict-of-interest recusal, whose decisions are recorded with a rationale.
- Written policies: non-discrimination practices, application requirements, recredentialing cycles, provider notification, and controls over who can change credentialing data.
- Delegation oversight: agreements and monitoring for any credentials verification organization (CVO) or other delegate that does part of the work.
Who needs a credentialing program?
Any organization that contracts with, employs, delegates to or manages healthcare providers needs one, whether or not it ever pursues accreditation.
- Medicaid managed care organizations operate under a federal provider selection rule. In plain terms, it directs states to ensure each plan has written selection and retention policies, a documented credentialing and recredentialing process, and no contracts with providers excluded from federal health care programs (42 CFR 438.214, Provider selection, page opened October 4, 2026).
- Independent physician associations and provider networks that credential their own members for health plans. The plan's delegation agreement states what it requires of a delegate, and IHS reads that agreement and builds to it.
- State primary care associations, FQHCs and community health centers forming networks that share credentialing across member sites.
- New health plan market entrants that need the program designed and running before launch, so the first review covers a program that has been operating.
What is shadow accreditation in credentialing?
Shadow accreditation is IHS's term for building a credentialing program that follows an accreditor's published standards as a benchmark without applying for the accreditor's survey. The organization gets the controls without the survey process. Whether a health plan or a state auditor accepts such a program is the plan's or auditor's decision, so check the delegation agreement or contract language that applies to you.
A program built this way is a stronger starting point if you later decide to pursue formal accreditation. IHS cannot promise that conversion will be easy, and any NCQA accreditation engagement is led by Maureen Plumstead.
Do I need NCQA accreditation to have a credentialing program?
That depends on what your health plan contracts and state Medicaid contract require, and those documents name it. NCQA's credentialing page currently shows Credentialing Accreditation, which covers the whole credentialing process including committee review, and Credentialing Certification, which covers the verification of practitioner credentials (NCQA, Credentialing Accreditation and Certification Programs, page opened October 4, 2026).
How does IHS design and implement a credentialing program?
IHS plans a program build as a 6 to 12 month engagement. That is an IHS planning range, not an accreditor or regulator figure. IHS provides templates, policy frameworks and expert guidance, and your team implements and operates the program.
| Phase | IHS planning range | What IHS delivers |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Standard-by-Standard Review and gap assessment | Months 1-2 | A review of your current credentialing files and procedures against the benchmark standards and your contract requirements, and a prioritized remediation roadmap |
| 2. Document preparation | Months 3-4 | Customized policies and templates: committee charter, PSV protocols, sanction escalation workflow, non-discrimination policy, data integrity policy, delegation agreement and oversight templates, application forms, monitoring procedures and recredentialing calendar |
| 3. Implementation support | Months 5-6 | Guidance on staff training, workflow changes and the first monitoring cycles, plus support for the first chartered committee meeting |
| 4. Mock review and corrective action | Months 7-8 | A review of a sample of files processed under the new program against the benchmark and your contract requirements, with corrective action plans |
| 5. Ongoing compliance guidance | Months 9-12 and beyond | Guidance as the program runs through its first monitoring, committee and audit cycles |
IHS plans time in the timeline for your team to operate the new procedures and generate records, so the first review covers a program that has been running. IHS offers optional monthly support after the build for standards changes, audit preparation and corrective action management. IHS does not serve as your compliance officer, and your organization's named contact, not IHS, communicates with regulators and accreditors.
Where does IHS look for gaps in an existing program?
These are the areas an IHS Standard-by-Standard Review checks. They are IHS's review focus, not a list of findings published by any accreditor.
- Primary source verifications that are out of date by the time the committee reviews the file
- Monitoring that relies on the recredentialing cycle alone, with no documented recurring checks between cycles
- Committee minutes that do not record each decision and its rationale
- No written escalation path when monitoring finds a sanctioned or excluded provider
- Data integrity audits that run but do not lead to corrective action
- Practitioner applications that do not match current policy
- Delegation agreements that do not state which functions a CVO performs, so the organization cannot show it oversees them
What does credentialing program design cost?
The cost has three parts: any accreditor fees, consulting fees, and your own staff time. A program built without pursuing the survey has no accreditor survey fee. NCQA's credentialing overview page lists no fee amounts and points to the NCQA Store for standards and survey tools (NCQA, Credentialing Accreditation and Certification Programs, page opened October 4, 2026). If you later pursue NCQA accreditation or certification, verify current fees with NCQA.
IHS sets a fixed fee for each engagement after a free discovery session, because scope, number of sites and gap severity change the work. For the cost drivers by organization type, see the credentialing program design cost guide.
How does IHS work on credentialing program design?
- IHS provides policy templates, procedure documents, committee charters and consulting guidance. It does not sell software or tie you to a platform, and the platform decision is yours.
- IHS builds the program to your actual contract and compliance requirements. If you need NCQA, Maureen Plumstead leads that work. If you need compliance without the accreditation seal, Dr. Goddard leads the program design.
- Dr. Goddard's JD and PhD shape the design for programs that must stand up to a payer or state review.
What this is not
- IHS is not an accrediting body and does not grant or influence an NCQA or any other accreditation decision.
- IHS drafts the program documents, and your clinicians review and approve them. Your organization's named contact submits anything that goes to a regulator or accreditor.
- This page is not legal advice, and a designed program does not guarantee that a plan, auditor or accreditor will accept it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a healthcare credentialing program and which organizations need one?
A healthcare credentialing program is the system an organization uses to verify provider qualifications, monitor them over time, and make enrollment decisions through a formal committee. Any organization that contracts with healthcare providers needs one, including Medicaid managed care organizations, independent physician associations seeking delegated credentialing, primary care associations and FQHCs forming networks, and new health plan market entrants.
What is the difference between credentialing, privileging, and provider enrollment?
Credentialing verifies that a provider's qualifications, such as education, licenses, certifications and work history, are authentic and current through primary source verification. Privileging determines the specific clinical services a provider may perform at a particular facility, which is primarily a hospital and facility function. Provider enrollment registers a provider with insurance payers so the provider can bill. IHS designs credentialing programs and does not design privileging or enrollment functions.
What does the federal Medicaid managed care provider selection rule require?
Under 42 CFR 438.214, states must ensure that managed care plans have written policies for selecting and retaining network providers, with a documented credentialing and recredentialing process. A plan cannot employ or contract with a provider excluded from federal health care programs, and it must meet any additional state requirements (42 CFR 438.214, Provider selection, page opened October 4, 2026).
Do I need NCQA accreditation for a compliant credentialing program?
It depends on what your health plan contracts and state Medicaid contract require. NCQA's credentialing page currently shows Credentialing Accreditation, which covers the whole credentialing process including committee review, and Credentialing Certification, which covers the verification of practitioner credentials (NCQA, Credentialing Accreditation and Certification Programs, page opened October 4, 2026). Read the contract language that applies to you before deciding.
What is shadow accreditation?
Shadow accreditation is IHS's term for a credentialing program built to an accreditor's published standards as a benchmark without applying for the survey. Plans and auditors decide whether they accept it. IHS designs these programs, and a program built this way is a stronger starting point for later accreditation.
How long does it take to build a credentialing program from scratch?
IHS plans a build as a 6 to 12 month engagement, and that is an IHS planning range. The timeline includes time for your team to operate the new procedures and generate records before an auditor or plan reviews the program.
Should we build a credentialing program internally or outsource to a CVO?
The answer depends on your network size, budget and how much control you want over governance. Some organizations outsource primary source verification and keep committee governance, policy oversight and escalation internally. IHS helps you evaluate both models and can design either. See the internal program and CVO outsourcing comparison.
Who is this not for?
This service is not for an organization that has decided to pursue NCQA accreditation or certification and wants that work led by an NCQA specialist, which is Maureen Plumstead's service, or for one that wants software. It is for organizations that need a credentialing program designed, documented and ready for a payer or state review.
Related resources
- Credentialing Program Design FAQ: more questions about building a credentialing program
- Credentialing Program Design Cost Guide: cost drivers by organization type
- Internal Program vs. CVO Outsourcing Comparison: build and buy compared
- NCQA Credentialing Certification Consulting: for organizations ready to pursue formal certification
- NCQA Credentialing Accreditation Consulting
- Program Development: the IHS practice line this service belongs to
Ready to build a credentialing program?
Schedule a conversation with IHS. We will look at your current credentialing operations, identify gaps against your contract requirements and a benchmark standard, and outline a roadmap to a program ready for a payer or state review.
