An accreditation-denial appeal is an organization's written request that its accreditor reverse a denial, filed under the accreditor's own published appeal policy and argued against the standards cited in the decision. Integral Healthcare Solutions (IHS) works for organizations that have received a denial: IHS analyzes the denial against your record and drafts the appeal your organization submits.
IHS is a healthcare consulting firm, not a law firm, and this page is not legal advice. The accreditor sets the deadline and makes the decision.
What is an accreditation-denial appeal?
Each accreditor publishes its own appeal or reconsideration process, so the governing text is that accreditor's policy plus the standards cited in the denial. Two examples:
URAC. In IHS's experience, URAC offers an appeal to an organization whose decision falls short of full accreditation. This page cannot tell you the URAC appeal period. Check your URAC decision letter and URAC's current appeal policy for it the day the decision arrives.
ACHC. Each ACHC program publishes its own accreditation process document. The Office-Based Surgery version sets a 30-calendar-day window for an appeal, counted from the date on ACHC's Denial letter, and the request goes to the organization's ACHC Account Advisor (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], Office-Based Surgery, revised 07/20/2023, page opened October 3, 2026). Money owed to ACHC bars an appeal: an unpaid balance or a lapsed payment plan ends the right to appeal, and so does filing after the 30-day window. It also has a separate Dispute Process for an individual deficiency on the Deficiency Assessment Report, with its own 10-calendar-day window that runs from receipt of that report; a challenge to a Denial itself goes through the appeal. Whether an organization holding both a Denial letter and a Deficiency Assessment Report has any use for the dispute path is IHS's reading of the document and is not settled; read Section VI.D and VI.E of your own program's process document immediately.
ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process sends an appeal to a committee of people with clinical or program expertise. The committee checks the survey against ACHC's own written process, and its decision cannot be reviewed further. An appeal turns on the record the surveyors had: the organization points to the findings it disputes and to documents the survey team already saw, and ACHC does not send submitted evidence back, so the organization should keep its own copies (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], Office-Based Surgery, revised 07/20/2023, page opened October 3, 2026).
Who needs it and what triggers it
- A URAC decision short of full accreditation. In IHS's experience, URAC offers an appeal in that situation.
- An ACHC Denial letter, which starts the 30-calendar-day period in the Office-Based Surgery process (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], Office-Based Surgery, revised 07/20/2023, page opened October 3, 2026).
- A missed ACHC Plan of Correction deadline. In the Office-Based Surgery process, an organization in Accreditation Pending status owes ACHC an approved Plan of Correction with evidence, due 10 calendar days from the Accreditation Pending letter. If that does not arrive in time, the status moves to Denial of Accreditation (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
Other accreditors' appeal policies were not part of the sources reviewed for this page; IHS reads the applicable policy from the accreditor's current document at the start of an engagement.
How IHS helps
IHS analyzes the denial against your record and drafts the appeal your organization submits. The work runs in this order:
- Gap assessment against the governing text. IHS reads the accreditor's appeal policy and every standard cited in the decision, then analyzes each cited finding, standard by standard, against the record your organization submitted.
- Document and evidence mapping. IHS sorts the findings into those already answered in the submitted record and those that would need new evidence, and builds an evidence index.
- Drafting. IHS drafts the appeal and the evidence index. Thomas G. Goddard, JD, PhD, writes the argument himself.
- Hearing preparation. Where the accreditor holds a hearing, IHS prepares your organization's representatives for it.
IHS's reading, October 2026: the ACHC Office-Based Surgery process lets an appeal rely only on documents the survey team had already seen (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026). On that reading, a finding that can be answered only with new evidence may not fit an ACHC appeal under that process, and the sorting step shows your organization which findings fall on each side. This is IHS's reading of one ACHC program document, not ACHC's statement, and other ACHC programs may differ.
What your organization supplies: the decision, the full submission and correspondence, any new evidence, and the name of the person who signs and sends the appeal.
The limit: your organization submits the appeal under its own name. IHS does not contact the accreditor and does not attend any hearing as your organization's representative.
What to have ready
Gather these before the introductory call:
- The denial or decision letter, with its date, since ACHC counts its 30-calendar-day period from that date (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], Office-Based Surgery, revised 07/20/2023, page opened October 3, 2026).
- The decision category the accreditor assigned, as stated in its decision letter.
- The Deficiency Assessment Report or equivalent findings list, since an ACHC appeal identifies the contested standards by reference to that report (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
- The date your organization received the Deficiency Assessment Report, since the ACHC Dispute Process runs 10 calendar days from receipt (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
- The full submission as sent, including policies, procedures and evidence files.
- Records of the documents the survey team saw, since an ACHC appeal can rely only on those (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
- All correspondence with the accreditor during the review.
- Any Plan of Correction submitted, with its evidence and dates (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
- Confirmation that nothing is owed to ACHC and that any installment arrangement is up to date, since ACHC will not grant an appeal while money is owing, including on an arrangement that has fallen behind (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026).
- Any new evidence created since the decision, kept separate from the submitted record.
- The name of the person who will sign and send the appeal.
Printable version of this checklist (PDF)
How it compares
An appeal is one of several paths after a denial. The accreditor's own text defines each.
| Path | What the published text says |
|---|---|
| Appeal (ACHC, Office-Based Surgery process) | Thirty calendar days from the Denial letter; the review looks at whether ACHC followed its own survey process, using only what the surveyors saw; the committee's ruling ends the matter (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026). |
| Reapply (ACHC) | After a Denial of Accreditation, an organization may reapply whenever it is ready for survey, with a new application (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026). |
| Appeal (URAC) | Offered to an organization whose decision falls short of full accreditation (IHS's description). Check your URAC decision letter and URAC's current appeal policy for the deadline. |
| Accreditation through a different body | For DMEPOS suppliers, CMS lists eight approved accreditation organizations (CMS list, updated 01/09/2026); each is approved for the product and service categories the list names, and the categories differ by organization. This is a general CMS list, not a statement by any accreditor about appeals. |
The choice among these belongs to your organization and depends on the findings, the deadline and the evidence available.
What it costs
ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process document names no appeal fee (ACHC [1227], page opened October 3, 2026). URAC does not publish its fees. Each applicant gets its fee in its URAC contract and pays it at signing. Verify current fees with ACHC and with URAC. ACHC will not accept an appeal while money is owing to it. IHS scopes each engagement after a free introductory call.
What this is not
- This is not legal advice, and IHS is not a law firm.
- IHS does not guarantee the accreditor's decision. The accreditor sets the deadline and decides, and under the Office-Based Surgery process an ACHC appeal ruling ends the matter.
- IHS does not submit the appeal, contact the accreditor, or attend a hearing as your representative. Your organization submits under its own name.
Frequently asked questions
Can we appeal an accreditation denial?
URAC and ACHC both have appeal processes. In IHS's experience, URAC offers an appeal to an organization whose decision falls short of full accreditation. ACHC's Office-Based Surgery accreditation process document (revised 07/20/2023) publishes an appeal process; check the process document for your own ACHC program.
How long do we have to appeal an ACHC denial?
In ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process document, revised 07/20/2023 (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], page opened October 3, 2026), an appeal request is due within 30 calendar days of the date on the Denial letter and is addressed to the organization's ACHC Account Advisor. Check the process document for your own ACHC program.
Who decides a URAC accreditation appeal?
Check the accreditor's appeal policy for who decides the appeal.
Can we submit new evidence in an accreditation appeal?
Under ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], page opened October 3, 2026), an appeal can rely only on documents the survey team had already seen. Other accreditors set their own rules, which IHS reads from the accreditor's current policy.
What is the difference between appealing a denial and reapplying?
An appeal asks ACHC to check its own survey process and either keep or lift the Denial. Reapplying means filing a new application, which ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], page opened October 3, 2026) allows whenever the organization is ready for survey.
What is URAC Corrective Action status, and is it the same as a denial?
Corrective Action and a denial are separate outcomes. Your decision letter names the outcome URAC assigned and what URAC requires in your case. Bring it to the introductory call.
What should an accreditation appeal letter contain?
In ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], page opened October 3, 2026), the request identifies the findings the organization disputes and attaches the documents the surveyors reviewed on site. IHS drafts the appeal and evidence index for the organization to submit.
Why are accreditation appeals denied?
In ACHC's Office-Based Surgery process (ACHC Accreditation Process [1227], page opened October 3, 2026), money owed to ACHC bars an appeal: an unpaid balance or a lapsed payment plan ends the right to appeal, and so does filing after the 30-day window. The process also ties an appeal to what the surveyors saw during the survey, and the committee's ruling ends the matter.
Should a lawyer or an accreditation consultant write the appeal?
Your organization decides whether to involve counsel. IHS is a consulting firm, not a law firm; it analyzes the findings against the record and drafts the appeal, with Thomas G. Goddard, JD, PhD, writing the argument, and your organization submits it.
